2 p.m.: Muscatine jury awards damages to woman in case against former lover (3262) Aug 7, 2008
Karly K. Rossiter, 25, of Winfield, Iowa, will receive 700,000 in compensatory damages, and 800,000 in punitive damages. The jury entered its decision on Aug. 1. (Muscatine Journal, IO)
Anthrax widow's press conference in WPB Aug 7, 2008
The lawsuit, also filed on behalf of the couple's three grown children, seeks a maximum of $50 million in compensatory damages for the government's alleged negligence in Stevens' death. . (The Palm Beach Post)
Judge Tosses $277M Jury Verdict in Securities Class Action Aug 6, 2008
Represented by lead trial counsel , the company was slapped with a $277 million compensatory damages verdict after jurors ruled that Apollo had misled investors. The decision was the largest investors' win since the was enacted in 1995. (Law.com)
Anthrax widow's suit blames government Aug 6, 2008
The lawsuit, also filed on behalf of the couple's three grown children, seeks a maximum of $50 million in compensatory damages for the government's alleged negligence in Stevens' death. Schuler said that figure represents the upper reaches of a possible damage award or settlement. (MSNBC -- Terrorism)
CVH Patient Sues Middletown, Mayor Aug 6, 2008
Messenger seeks a cease-and-desist order against Giuliano and Perez, as well as punitive and compensatory damages and attorney's fees. Related links. (FOX61, CT)
NiSource Reports Second Quarter Earnings Aug 5, 2008
As previously reported, on May 22, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals declined to review the trial court judgment in the case, which included compensatory damages of approximately $134 million and punitive damages of approximately $270 million. The West Virginia Supreme Court subsequently granted NiSource's request for a stay of the judgment, pending action by the U.S. Supreme Court on a petition for a writ of certiorari, which NiSource plans to file in late August. (PR Newswire)
How Texans voted in Congress Aug 3, 2008
The bill empowers women alleging pay bias to sue for recovery of back pay and receive punitive and compensatory damages; bans employer retaliation against those who share salary data with co-workers, and establishes a grant program to teach negotiating skills to girls and women. A yes vote was to pass the bill. (Houston Chronicle)
Punitive Damages Not Recoverable in Doctor's Suit Over Dismissal Jul 31, 2008
5 million in punitives, plus another $1 million in compensatory damages and interest, after presenting evidence that Cooper University Hospital in Camden, N.J., violated his contract when it dismissed him from the cardiology department in 2001 ... 5 million, affirmed the compensatory damages and calculated interest, bringing the total to slightly less than $2 ... Barring a successful appeal to the state Supreme Court, the punitive damage claim will be absent from the retrial on liability and... (Law.com)
Ethanol plant action sought Jul 31, 2008
The Empire State Ethanol lawsuit, filed June 13, seeks $57 million in compensatory damages and $18 million in punitive damages along with attorneys' fees. Eric Anderson can be reached at 454-5323 or by e-mail at eanderson@timesunion. (Albany Times Union)
Pilots file suit against DHL Jul 31, 2008
The pilots union has asked the court to enjoin DHL from switching service to UPS. ALPA also asks for compensatory damages and attorney's fees. ALPA says 10,000 pilots and other DHL employees will lose their jobs with the switch to UPS.. (Dayton Business Journal, OH)
School district accused of age discrimination Jul 31, 2008
Hart s suit contends that she sustained a diminished salary, emotional damages, expected future damages and other compensatory damages as a result of the district s actions. Groat later accused Hart of unprofessional conduct for allegedly organizing a June 5, 2007 student protest against her termination. (Hudson Register Star, NY)
Gibson Dunn Will Fight Court's $13.4 Million Reversal in Crash Case Jul 29, 2008
Boutrous says the huge reward, which is nearly triple the $5 million awarded in compensatory damages, violates due process because there is no way DCC could have anticipated that its conduct could be punished to such a degree. In particular, Boutrous says the court's decision to allow evidence of similar injuries that occurred after the crash at the center of the case comes close to penalizing DCC for injuries suffered by other parties not named in the suit -- something tort reformers hoped... (Law.com)
Cemetery to pay for burial errors Jul 27, 2008
A state Supreme Court jury awarded six relatives compensatory damages of 45,000 each in a negligence suit against the cemetery. A decision on punitive damages which could amount to 2. (Auburn Citizen, NY)
Court Upholds $13 Million in Punitives Against DaimlerChrysler Jul 26, 2008
The family was also awarded $5 million in compensatory damages, but those were upheld by an appeals court. "Chrysler's position has always been that this case was never a punitive damages case," Palese said. (Law.com)
Damages awarded in Colonie grave misplacements Jul 26, 2008
Six relatives will each receive $45,000 in compensatory damages, and could share more than $2. 4 million depending on punitive damages to be decided next week, their attorneys said. (Albany Times Union)
Teed Off at Not Teeing Up, Giuliani's Son Sues Over Dismissal From School Golf Team Jul 25, 2008
The lawsuit seeks unspecified compensatory damages and the right to use the while he is in school and after he graduates. It also seeks a jury trial. (Law.com)
Motorsport chief wins orgy court case Jul 25, 2008
Page last updated at 17:29 GMT, Thursday, 24 July 2008 18:29 UK. Mosley wins court case over orgy. (BBC News -- Europe)
Top US Court Near Decision on Exxon Valdez Interest Payments Jul 24, 2008
In its 5-3 decision on June 25, the Supreme Court reduced the punitive damages to the level of compensatory damages, or the actual harm suffered by the spill victims. The majority said a 1- 1 ratio with compensatory damages was ``a fair upper limit'' in maritime cases that don't involve intentional wrongdoing or a company effort to ``augment profit. (Bloomberg)
Court's Exxon Valdez ruling called unfair Jul 24, 2008
Although the Supreme Court decision applies solely to maritime law, the justices also suggested that when juries assess punitive damages to punish corporate wrongdoers, they use a 1-to-1 ratio based on the amount of compensatory damages awarded ... The compensatory damages were low in the case because the court failed to take into account the long-term effect of losing a way of life, said Schultz, who fished with her husband in Prince William Sound at the time of the spill. (Anchorage Daily News)
Former deputy files suit against King & Rogers Jul 24, 2008
She is seeking compensatory damages not to exceed $1,000,000 and punitive damages not to exceed $5,000,000. She is also requesting a jury trial. (Camden Chronicle, TN)
Attorney General's Role in Tobacco Settlement Precludes Punitive Damages Suit, Panel Rules Jul 23, 2008
Murray Garnick, Altria client services senior vice president and associate general counsel, speaking on behalf of Philip Morris USA, said, "Philip Morris USA believes the appellate court reached the legally correct decision in barring an individual plaintiff from seeking punitive damages. The ruling still permits the award of compensatory damages in individual cases." ... In August 2007, Justice Ramos denied the tobacco companies' motion for summary judgment with respect to both punitive and... (Law.com)
Our Soldiers Must Conduct Themselves Jul 22, 2008
The ideal case-scenario would be for the victims to sue the Ghana Armed Forces for compensatory damages. This is absolutely no joking matter. (Ghana Web, Ghana)
Update: Facebook Sues The German Social Networking Site studiVZ Jul 21, 2008
According to the complaint, Facebook seeks "to end StudiVZ's illegal activity" and compensatory damages in an amount to be determined at trial, Reuters reported. Facebook is a social-networking site that has managed to gain over 80 million users worldwide since it was launched in 2004, and Mark Zuckerberg, the founder of the Facebook, is among the worlds youngest billionaires. (eFluxMedia)
Turnpike files suit against Belhaven Jul 20, 2008
In the complaint s prayer for relief, the company asks the Beaufort County Superior Court to enter a judgment requiring the town to specifically perform each of its obligations under the agreement and that the company be awarded compensatory damages in an amount in excess of 10,000 ... As part of the company s complaint against the town, Turnpike is asking for compensatory damages. (Washington Daily News, NC)
Family sues for $20 million in police shooting Jul 19, 2008
The civil lawsuit requests "at least $20 million" in compensatory damages and alleges wrongful death, assault and battery in regards to Deputy Williamson's actions, negligence of duty as an officer and "negligent training and supervision" of the Sheriff's Office. "These officers basically create their own laws that they follow," the family's attorney, Brian Claypool, said Thursday from his office in Los Angeles. (Daily Triplicate)
Woman sues surgeon for unwanted tattoo below her panty line! Jul 19, 2008
Mateo is seeking punitive and compensatory damages. (ANI). (Fresh News)
Lawsuit filed in youth's death Jul 18, 2008
Bolten is seeking compensatory damages of an unknown amount and punitive damages of 500,000, plus attorney fees. Bolten is represented by attorney Jeffrey J. Hosford of Starkville. (Webster Progress-Times, MS)
Unser Sr. files suit alleging mistreatment by deputies Jul 17, 2008
The lawsuit also seeks punitive and compensatory damages to be decided by a jury. Unser had offered to settle the claims for $700,000, provided the records were expunged, McNeill said. (Boston Globe)
Former SG Knocks Pro-Business Label for High Court Jul 17, 2008
Clement said the Court's ruling in related to the Exxon Valdez oil spill, was "fascinating." In his majority opinion, Justice David Souter , ruling punitives should generally be no more than compensatory damages. The 1-to-1 ratio is "the most pro-defendant, anti-plaintiff rule" of any of the circuit courts that have ruled on the issue, Clement said. (Law.com)
Drug companies agree to settlement Jul 17, 2008
Under the agreement, Bristol-Myers Squibb and Apothecon will provide certain pricing information to Idaho Medicaid and pay Idaho 1,738,719 for restitution and compensatory damages. The state will receive 500,573 plus attorneys fees and costs. (Pocatello Idaho State Journal, ID)
A former officer sues MP police chief, capt. Jul 17, 2008
Cook filed the lawsuit against Wilson and Goetz individually and is seeking unspecified compensatory damages from the two. She also is asking to be awarded the cost of the trial, and further relief as the court deems proper. (Columbia Daily Herald, TN)
Powell Goldstein's $2 Million Punitive Win to Face Challenge Jul 16, 2008
A federal jury in Atlanta -- sympathetic to a software firm that was unceremoniously tossed out of a national technology conference by the host firm -- has hit the conference host with $260,925 in combined compensatory damages and $2 ... 5 million, equal to what was awarded in compensatory damages in the case ... "People have been looking for some guidance about what the relationship ought to be between punitive and compensatory damages," said Colangelo. (Law.com)
Pa. High Court to Hear Appeal in High-Profile Kia Class Action Jul 16, 2008
If it's a substantive due process claim, Donovan said, the case involves compensatory damages, not punitive damages, and Kia had an opportunity to present all of its defenses at both the trial and appellate level. On the fee issues, Kia argues in court papers that a plain reading of the MMWA doesn't permit entry of an award of attorney fees after judgment in a case that has already been entered and does not permit an award of fees on a risk multiplier. (Law.com)
County fair ride suit at a standstill Jul 16, 2008
Graves' suit alleges deliberate infliction of emotional distress and negligent and reckless conduct leading to "an abrupt and violent striking of the ground." He seeks $125,000 in compensatory damages and any other penalties the court deems proper. Initial investigations indicated a mechanical failure in the ride's hub disrupted the normal rotation of the wheel and caused the spinning seats to begin colliding with one another. (The Union Democrat)
Court lowers corrections officer's award Jul 14, 2008
Following a hearing and recommendations by an administrative law judge, Humig was awarded compensatory damages in the amount of $850,000. However, the appeals court stated that while Humig testified that she suffered ailments from physical, mental and emotional due to the alleged discriminatory actions, Humig attended only four counseling sessions. (Buffalo Business First, NY)
Judge Tosses $27 Million Award in Hormone Drug Lawsuit Jul 13, 2008
75 million in compensatory damages and $27 million in punitive damages ... Wilson has already upheld the jury's compensatory damages award. (Law.com)
After High Court Ruling, Exxon Valdez Families Ask if They Can Collect Millions in Interest Jul 13, 2008
In , the justices imposed a 1:1 ratio of compensatory to punitive damages, and said they took for granted the district court's calculation of the compensatory damages at $507. 5 million. (Law.com)
Award increased to IS&S in trade-secrets case Jul 8, 2008
maker of monitoring and display equipment for aircraft said the United States District Court for the Western District of Tennessee awarded it damages, interest and fees in addition to the compensatory damages awarded by a jury in November 2007. The defendants in the case are former IS&S (NASDAQ:ISSC) employee Joseph Caesar; former IS&S sales consultant James Zachary; J2 Inc., which Caesar and Zachary owned and founded; Zachary Technologies Inc., which Zachary owned and founded; and Merrimack,... (Philadelphia Business Journal, PA)
Termite attorney exterminator-proof Jul 7, 2008
When he's not reading Pest Control Magazine or visiting the Terminix or Orkin Web sites to double-check termite trivia for any one of the 41 bug cases he's handling worth, he estimates, a potential $40 million to $60 million in compensatory damages he's plotting strategy against his adversaries. He has plenty. (The Palm Beach Post)
TROY Group, Inc. Posts Second Quarter 2008 Results Jul 4, 2008
The complaint seeks various forms of legal and equitable relief, including without limitation unspecified compensatory damages, attorneys' fees and costs, and declaratory relief. The consolidated balance sheet and consolidated statement of income are attached to this press release. (PR Newswire)
Drug Companies Asked to Settle Jul 4, 2008
He estimates about $1,000,000,000 of compensatory damages are still out there. Add on to that 6% interest. (WSJA.com, AL)
2 Drug Firms to Appeal $114M Price Fraud Verdict Jul 4, 2008
Montgomery attorney Jere Beasley, who is representing the state in the lawsuits, said Thursday the state could receive as much as $1 billion in compensatory damages if it wins the remaining 69 cases. "So far the verdicts have been very good to Alabama," Beasley said. (ABC News -- Wire)
Black mark left on judicial system Jul 4, 2008
Justice David Souter wrote in the opinion that punitive damages should never be any higher than compensatory damages. Those are the ones that reimburse victims for actual costs they can prove, like the loss of fishing income after an oil leak. (Racine Journal Times, WI)
UniFirst records 24% rise in third-quarter earnings Jul 3, 2008
5 million in damages, including $5 million in punitive damages, later cut to the legal limit of $300,000 under the Americans with Disabilities Act and in October 2006 compensatory damages were trimmed to $600,000, citing New York state law. Wal-Mart denied discriminating against disabled workers. (Boston Globe)
Novartis plans to appeal $33M loss in Alabama court claiming it overcharged for drugs Jul 3, 2008
The jury rejected the state's claims for punitive damages but decided against Novartis on the state's claims for compensatory damages, awarding $33 million. On Feb. 21, the first of the average wholesale price cases to be tried resulted in a verdict for $215 million against the AstaZeneca pharmaceutical company. (Birmingham Business Journal)
Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation to Appeal Judgment in Alabama Pricing Case Jul 2, 2008
Jury verdict in Montgomery County Circuit Court awards $33 million in compensatory damages Jury decides in favor of Novartis and rejects claims for punitive damages NPC maintains it reported true and accurate prices and will file appeal EAST HANOVER, N.J., July 1 /PRNewswire/ -- Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation (NPC) today announced it will appeal a verdict in the Montgomery County Circuit Court ... The jury rejected the State's claims for punitive damages but decided against NPC on the... (PR Newswire)
Wal-Mart Loses $6.5 Million Wage-and-Hour Class Action Jul 2, 2008
5 million in compensatory damages to the class, which consists of about 56,000 Wal-Mart employees in Minnesota. King's ruling follows a and a. (Law.com)
DAILY DIGEST Jul 2, 2008
8 million in compensatory damages and that Novartis should pay $33. 7 million in similar damages. (San Francisco Chronicle -- Business)
Jury Awards State Millions Jul 2, 2008
The jury awarded the state a little more than $33,000,000 in compensatory damages from Novartis Pharmaceutical Company and almost $81,000,000 in compensatory damages from GlaxoSmithKline also known as GSK. ... "Certainly, I agree with the jury that punitive damages weren't warranted here - that none should have been awarded and they weren't. We're disappointed with the verdict as to compensatory damages. It's been our position all along that GlaxoSmithKline reported true and accurate prices.". (WSJA.com, AL)
Lilly agrees to settle discrimination lawsuit Jul 2, 2008
Lilly will pay Johnson $54,400 in severance pay and $7,000 in interest and compensatory damages, according to a settlement order filed for the case in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana ... compensatory damages. (Yahoo News -- Pharmaceutical Industry News)
Former Old Forge cop sues borough, claims rights violated, discrimination Jul 2, 2008
The suit which is asking for compensatory damages, back pay, front pay, attorneys fees and letters of good reference names as defendants Mr. Torquato, Old Forge Borough, Old Forge Police Department and former Borough Council members David Scarnato, Alan Heyen and Shirley Helbing. It also names Old Forge Police Chief Larry Semenza, the police officers association, the borough s Civil Service Commission and its chairman, James Minella. (Scranton Times, PA)
Ex-teacher's lawsuit tied to debate over play Jul 2, 2008
Willis, 41, is suing for $100,000 in special damages and $25,000 in compensatory damages. He now works at The Broadway Rose Theatre Company in Tigard as an education and outreach manager. (OregonLive, OR -- News)
Daily Briefing Jul 2, 2008
8 million in compensatory damages and that Novartis should pay about $33 ... 5 million in compensatory damages, but Wal-Mart could end up paying much more than that after a jury in October considers civil penalties and punitive damages. (Atlanta Journal-Constitution -- Business)
Wal-Mart Loses Lawsuit Over Work Breaks Jul 2, 2008
5 million in compensatory damages. An attorney for the plaintiffs expects Wal-Mart will pay much more than that after a jury in October considers a civil penalties and punitive damages. (CBS News -- US)
Judge rules against Wal-Mart on work breaks Jul 2, 2008
5 million in compensatory damages, but Wal-Mart could end up paying more than $2 billion after a jury in October considers civil penalties and punitive damages ... While the plaintiffs won't receive compensatory damages for those violations, Wal-Mart is subject to a $1,000 civil penalty for each incident. (San Diego Union-Tribune -- Business)
Jury: 2 drug firms owe state $114 million Jul 2, 2008
8 million in compensatory damages and that Novartis should pay about $33. 7 million in similar damages. (AL.com)
Jury: 2 drug firms owe Ala. $114M in price fraud Jul 2, 2008
8 million in compensatory damages and that Novartis should pay about $33 ... The jury awarded the amount of compensatory damages Beasley had asked for in closing arguments ... "I think the jury looked at the evidence and decided the fraud was substantial but that the compensatory damages plus interest was enough," Beasley said. (AL.com)
Punitives Take Hit in 'Exxon' Ruling, but How Hard? Jul 1, 2008
5 million after holding that a 1-to-1 ratio of punitive to compensatory damages is a "fair upper limit" in maritime cases in order to protect against "unpredictable and unnecessary" awards. Souter concluded that the ratio was the appropriate tool after reviewing a variety of other approaches to protecting against the "stark unpredictability" of punitive awards, such as verbal formulations superimposed on general jury instructions, and finding those approaches ineffective. (Law.com)
Jury Now Has Case Against Two Drug Companies in Alabama Jul 1, 2008
Attorney Jere Beasley, representing the state, told jurors in closing arguments Monday that GlaxoSmithKline should have to pay almost $81 million in compensatory damages and as much as $500 million in punitive damages. Beasley said Novartis Pharmaceuticals should have to pay about $33 million in compensatory damages and between up to $200 million in punitive damages. (WSJA.com, AL)
High court affirms right to own guns Jun 29, 2008
The court found that punitive damages could not be larger than the compensatory damages for actual losses from the spill, which totaled $507. 5 million. (Seattle Times)
Exxon Ruling Big Win For Business Jun 29, 2008
"The award should be limited to an amount equal to compensatory damages." ... Robin Conrad, executive vice president of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's National Chamber Litigation Center, says the decision "could have an effect far beyond federal maritime law" because by limiting punitive damages awards to no more than that paid for compensatory damages. (Forbes -- Business)
Letters to the Editor (6/27/08) Jun 28, 2008
What they focused on was the exxon valdez case being so far out of the norm of 1 to 1 with compensatory damages. Punitive damages are meant to alter behavior of bad actors, not to give people as much as they expected. (Anchorage Daily News)
Ruling stuns spill victims Jun 27, 2008
Punitive damages and compensatory damages already paid to plaintiffs don't begin to pay for that loss alone, he said. "It really hurts," he said of Wednesday's ruling. (Juneau Empire)
Cost to Exxon: eight days’ profit Jun 27, 2008
Each of the 33,000 people who filed a claim against the company will receive an average payment of about $15,000, in addition to the original $15,000 they received in compensatory damages. The cost to ExxonMobil, including the compensatory and punitive damages, is the equivalent of about eight days profit, based on the company s reported earnings for the first quarter. (Scranton Times, PA)
Alaskans call oil-spill payment 'tragic' Jun 27, 2008
"This case was about punishment and whether further punishment was warranted. It was not about compensatory damages." ... The court's majority found that Exxon had acted without "intentional or malicious conduct," and a 1-to-1 ratio of punitive to compensatory damages "is a fair upper limit in such maritime cases," according to the decision penned by Justice David Souter. (Christian Science Monitor)
